Most Windows disk space monitors suck

GMass runs on a farm of Windows servers, and as the chief systems administrator, one of the constant worries in the back of my mind is whether any of the disks on any of the servers is near capacity. Naturally, I decided to Google “Windows disk space monitor”.

Given the usefulness of such a tool for any Windows server administrator like myself, I was expecting to be overwhelmed with viable options. Not only was I not overwhelmed, but the first two disk space monitors I downloaded sucked — to the point that I can’t even believe they are on the first page of Google. It goes to show that Google’s search results don’t always yield the best tools, just the most popular. Case in point, GMass is probably the world’s best Gmail mail merge tool, but a search for “Gmail mail merge” and GMass is shown near the bottom of page 1 and sometimes at the top of page 2. Yes, competition for that term is stiff indeed.

But I digress. Googling for “Windows disk space monitor” produces the following tools, and in this order:

  1. The Microsoft Performance Logs and Alerts technique
  2. A tool called Netwrix Disk Space Monitor from Netwrix
  3. A full server monitoring tool called PRGT from a company called Paessler
  4. A tool called Disk Monitor Lite from ManageEngine
  5. A tool called Meerkat, written by a sole developer and not backed by a real company
  6. A tool called Advanced Disk Space Monitor from Abaiko Software

Before I explain why 4 out of these 5 suck, let me first explain exactly what I wanted in the right disk space monitoring software:

  1. It should run as a service, so that if the server re-boots itself in the middle of the night, my disk space is still being monitored.
  2. It should have the ability to email me at defined thresholds, either in actual amount of space left or percentage of space left.

That’s all — just two simple requirements that most software calling itself “disk space monitoring” software failed to meet. Let’s break it down.

Windows Performance Logs and Alerts

The options to be alerted include: logging an entry in the Application Event Log, sending a network message to another server, initiating a performance data log, or running an EXE. That’s right — no email option, no text message option. How does Microsoft not understand the importance of email? They bought Hotmail in the late 90s, created Microsoft Exchange as their own email server platform, and now compete head-to-head against Gmail with Outlook.com. Yet the notion that a sysadmin would want to get an email to alert them of impending server doom is somehow lost upon them.

Why it sucks: No option to be emailed.

Netwrix Disk Space Monitor

A simple, and supposedly free tool, that at first glance, I was convinced would solve my problem and my search would be over. Ehhh, not quite. Here’s a screenshot of the email settings. Let’s see if you can figure out what’s missing:

On the surface, it looks like it has everything you need to have an email sent to yourself when there’s a disk space issue. SMTP server, recipient address, From address. But wait…there’s no place to input SMTP server login information. Pretty much every SMTP server in the universe requires authentication by username and password (a few still let you authenticate by IP address), but given that there’s a thing called “spam” nowadays, Netwrix’s tool would only work circa 1999, when most SMTP servers were still open relays.

Why it sucks: No option to authenticate into the SMTP server.

Disk Monitor Lite

Total misnomer. Does some cool stuff and generates a cool report, but it doesn’t actually do any monitoring. That’s right — while it can generate on-demand reports, if you look at its feature list, nowhere will you find the ability to be alerted upon low disk space.

Why it sucks: No actual monitoring.

Paessler PRTG Network Monitor

I’m betting that this tool would have done exactly what I wanted, but figuring out how to get it to do it was a hurdle I was unwilling to cross. This tool does a lot. And as such, it’s UI is complex. All I cared about was knowing when my disks were about to fill up, and this tool does 1,000 things more. Along with installing three different applications (the Network Monitor, the Administration Tool, and the Enterprise Console) to your Windows Start menu, there are at least two different user interfaces to manage.

Here’s what I saw when I first installed and launched the tool:

And here is the Enterprise Console.

Do you see any prompts that ask at what disk space threshold I want to be alerted? Neither do I. Next.

Why it sucks: It probably doesn’t, but it’s complicated as hell.

Meerkat

At the bottom of page 1 of the Google search results was a little tool called Meerkat. I liked that it was called “meerkat”, and I liked that it was created and explained by a sole developer. And obviously, I liked that it was free. Let’s go right to a screenshot:

Meerkat Disk Space Monitor
Meerkat Disk Space Monitor “Disks” settings

Nice. It shows me my disks, let me check the ones to monitor, and set the free space threshold to be alerted.

Meerkat Disk Space Monitor
Meerkat Disk Space Monitor “Options”

And look at that…right below the space where I set my SMTP server, I set my SMTP server username and password. Beautiful. I think I have a winner, until I go to my second server to install it. The install fails because I have .NET 4.7 installed (the latest), and it ONLY works with 3.5:

Meerkat sucks
Meerkat won’t install unless you have exactly .NET 3.5 installed.

Why it sucks: It requires a very specific .NET version, 3.5, to run. If you have anything greater, like version 4.7, which is the latest right now, it won’t install.

Advanced Disk Space Monitor (the WINNER)

You have to go to page 2 of the search results to find the one tool that doesn’t suck. It doesn’t suck because it lets you define your thresholds for each disk individually. It doesn’t suck because it will email you an alert when you’re running out of space.

Advanced Disk Space Monitor Screenshot
The general disk space settings for Advanced Disk Space Monitor

It doesn’t suck because it lets you configure a username and password for the SMTP server through which the email is sent. And finally, it doesn’t suck, because it will actually run on a Windows server with the latest .NET framework installed. Beautiful. We have a winner. It will, however, cost you $20 per license. But after all the effort I’ve put in so far, $100 for five servers is nothing.

Advanced Disk Space Monitor Screenshot
The email settings for Advanced Disk Space Monitor

Why it sucks: It doesn’t! It’s awesome.

One more option

After I found my winner, I stopped my search, but if you continue scanning through page 1 and 2 of the search results, you’ll find one more tool called Overseer. I did not sample this tool for my research, but if for some reason Advanced Disk Space Monitor doesn’t float your boat, check this one out, and perhaps comment on it below. It has a long hyphenated domain name, which looks unprofessional to me, but I forgive them because finding the right domain to launch a software product is damn near impossible these days.

TL;DR

Most Windows disk space monitors suck. The one that doesn’t, Advanced Disk Space Monitor, will not be found on page 1 of a Google search of “Windows disk space monitor.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *